Should you work for an independent or a restricted advice firm?
Neither is automatically the better career choice. Independent and restricted advisers need the same Level 4 qualification and Statement of Professional Standing, and both must give suitable advice. The difference is how the firm chooses the products it recommends, which shapes your research, training, processes and clients. For a trainee, the quality of supervision and client exposure usually matters more than the label.
This guide looks at the choice from the point of view of someone joining a firm, not a client choosing an adviser. For the full route into advice, see our guide to becoming a financial adviser in the UK.
What is the difference between independent and restricted advice?
The rules are in section 6.2B of the FCA’s Conduct of Business Sourcebook, which have applied since January 2018 and replaced the earlier Retail Distribution Review guidance, as the FCA explains in PS18/10.
- Independent advice. A firm that says it is independent must assess a sufficient range of products on the market. That range must be diverse in type and in provider, and must not be limited to the firm’s own products or those of firms it has close links or contracts with. Independent firms may use panels, but a panel has to be broad enough and reviewed regularly.
- Restricted advice. Advice that is not independent is restricted. The restriction might be to certain types of product, to a limited number of providers, or to a single provider. Restricted advice is still regulated advice, and the FCA expects a restricted firm not to make a recommendation if nothing in its range meets the client’s needs.
Both kinds of firm must tell clients, in good time before giving advice, whether their advice is independent or restricted, using those words. Where advice is restricted, the adviser must also say so out loud before giving advice in a conversation. Prospects describes the same two types of adviser in its careers profile.
What stays the same whichever firm you join?
More than many candidates expect. To give retail investment advice you need an FCA-recognised Level 4 qualification, a Statement of Professional Standing renewed each year and continuing professional development, as set out in the FCA’s professional standards for advisers. Those standards apply to independent and restricted advisers alike. Our financial adviser qualifications guide covers the options in detail.
The core of the job is the same too: understanding a client’s circumstances and goals, explaining options in plain English, recording why a recommendation is suitable and reviewing it over time. The National Careers Service lists independent financial adviser as one alternative title for the same job.
How does the model change your day to day work?
Every firm is different, so treat these as questions to explore rather than rules.
- Research and product selection. In an independent firm you may spend more time on research and due diligence, or work closely with whoever builds and reviews the firm’s panel. In a restricted firm the range is usually set centrally, so you learn that range in depth.
- Process and structure. Some restricted firms are large, with set processes, central training and in-house systems. Independent firms range from very small practices to large groups, so the structure you get varies widely.
- Clients and specialisms. Some firms specialise, for example in retirement planning or business owners. A firm can focus on a specific range and still be independent, if it markets itself only to clients who want that range and checks that its service suits each new client.
- Self-employment later on. Prospects notes that some advisers later become self-employed, by joining a network as an IFA or setting up their own business. If that appeals, ask how people who have left the firm have gone on.
What matters most for a trainee adviser?
When you are starting out, the firm’s model matters less than how it develops you. Look for:
- Supervision. Who will supervise and assess you, and how often will they sit in on your work?
- Client exposure. Will you attend client meetings early on, and when will you start leading parts of them?
- Study support. Does the firm pay for exams and give study time?
- A clear plan. What does the path from trainee to competent adviser look like, and how long does it usually take?
- Clients. Will you look after existing clients, build your own, or a mix?
Our guide to becoming a trainee financial adviser covers these in more depth, and the paraplanner to adviser guide is written for people moving from a technical role.
How can you tell which kind of firm it is?
Start with the firm’s website and its client documents, which should say “independent advice” or “restricted advice”. You can check a firm’s authorisation on the FCA Financial Services Register. Some firms offer both kinds of advice. If so, the rules require the two services, and the advisers giving them, to be kept clearly separate, so ask which service you would be joining.
Then ask about it at interview. Useful questions include:
- How does the firm choose the products and providers it recommends, and who reviews that?
- What part will I play in research, and what support will I have?
- Why did the firm choose its model, and has it changed?
Being able to explain the difference clearly will also help you answer questions about it. Our trainee financial adviser interview questions guide has more on preparing.
Can you move between independent and restricted firms later?
Yes. Because the qualification and professional standards are the same, it is possible to move between the two during a career. Moving means learning a new product range or research process and new systems, and your new firm will need to be satisfied that you are competent in its way of working. It does not mean starting your qualifications again.
How IFA Talent can help
We recruit for independent and restricted advice firms, as well as wealth and planning businesses, so we can talk through what a particular firm’s model would mean for you. We give honest feedback, insight into a firm’s culture, support and progression, and help with interview preparation and weighing up offers. Everything is confidential, and nothing is shared with a firm until you have told us that it is okay. You can also browse our open roles or read more guides.